Chase This Light With Me

It's a well known fact that Jimmy Eat World's albums Clarity, Bleed American and Futures are arguably their best work to date. So why is it that every time I crave a little Jimmy, I go to Chase This Light? It's alright, but not nearly as good as the three aforementioned titles. I think it's the stellar first track that lures me in, and a solid final three tracks that keeps me listening.